First, Asalaamaliekum.
This has been a long project,
especially for walking into the middle of it. WAFSP stands for West
Africa Food Security Program and is in affiliation with USAID which is in
affiliation with Peace Corps in that PCV's are the ones on the ground here
utilizing tax payer money in as sustainable ways as we can to promote food
secure projects and activities.
The volunteer in the town over wrote
a grant to help her school have the funds to procure a garden. There was
nothing but a plot of land to begin with. The grant money rehabilitated
the hand pump, procured a chain link fence, provided a garden training, seeds,
garden tools, and ally-cropping fruit trees, and of course, appropriate signs
showing off USAID and Peace Corps logos- can't forget the publicity part.
By the time I took over the project
(the volunteer had to leave their service early for personal reasons) the grant
had been submitted but the money hadn’t yet hit the bank. My responsibility was making sure the money
went where it was supposed to and that a garden got made. The most difficult part of this project, and
probably any project handover, is not knowing the community or the people like
I know my own. It’s easier to work with
strangers from your own country because you innately have a better idea of the
culture and where people are coming from since you are coming from similar places. But here, I may never know or fully understand
where people are coming from because I did not spend my childhood here. So the best I can do is get to know my
community as best I can and work within that.
And every village is different just like every person is different. And so the same goes for the large town receiving
the garden.
The most disappointing thing was the
attitude of the formed garden committee.
We held a training and they continued to ask about logistics which was
the polite way of asking where there money was.
Because so much foreign aid has been pumped into this country, it seems
to be that people just expect things now and don’t necessarily truly value or
care about those things themselves but care that they are being given
something. Charity is one of the five
pillars of Islam and so that expectation goes deeper and further than foreign
aid. Nearly $5000 US dollars was pumped
into this project to establish a potentially highly productive vegetable garden
to promote gardening and healthy eating at the school and in the community. Instead of being excited about that outcome,
which granted does take time and work, they were disappointed that there was no
per diem. After a long discussion I
stuck to my guns and refused to offer per diem.
They got a training, and a very nice lunch, and a garden. The grant doesn’t allow per diem anyway. I had to try to explain how Peace Corps was
different than Unicef and Actionaid and WFP.
We are not an organization that gives money but an organization that
builds capacity. This was rather lost on
them. At any rate they told me that if
there was no money there was no motivation to attend any more trainings which
was honestly fine by me as the garden is for the students anyway and they don’t
need per diem to attend a training.
I told them honestly, in English so
I’m not sure how much was heard but I definitely cannot speak Wolof whilst
frustrated, that had I known per diem was their motivation from the get go and
had I know they wouldn’t show an interest in the actual garden, I wouldn’t have
volunteered to help see this project thru taking my time out of my own village
away from people that actually care about projects, and not just per diem.
You can’t get too upset though. A training takes you away from your other
duties and you want to see compensation.
I understand that. Heck if I ever
have to come down for a “mandatory” training, as a Vollunteer! I want compensation too which Peace Corps does provide. But the trainings I attend are not giving me
things like a $5000 vegetable garden.
They just give us skills and knowledge to help people better help
themselves. So I feel that they are
somehow different. It’s also an
interesting culture difference that here, in order to motivate people to attend
trainings or workshop, there needs to be something like money, lunch, juice, or
snack while in the states we typically have to pay for the trainings and
workshops we attend. But there often is
food and tea at those as well.
It’s just very unfortunate that
foreign aid seems to do more harm than good in the sense that it has created an
attitude of expectation for things and assistance which practically eliminates
the motivation to help oneself. And I
don’t blame them. The work here is
exhausting. I admittedly cannot do it
and nor do I try or feel guilty anymore for not going to the field every day or
for asking for help once in a while to fetch water. Not only is it exhausting work but it’s work
that is being done on a very very small calorie diet (maybe 1200-1800 depending
on how well off your family is).
But the students and school itself
is stepping up in showing interest after some more pep talks. Since the training they have created 12 beds
and have been watering the nursery. This
is a big deal! They can only benefit
from doing the work but let’s be honest, it’s even hard to get people to garden
in the states!
Dear Sam,
ReplyDeleteThis problem exists even in the USA. US gov used to pay for art students to retrain in Computer or other areas where they could make money. I was a grad w/BA from NYU looking for work. I went to the classes for RPG2, a computer language. There were about 25 students of which 2 were working on learning the language. The rest did no homework or put in any effort beside showing up. By showing up they got paid. I left the class for I found work but I was one of the two working. It was very frustrating to see the lack of ethics. I would say that what you see in Gambia is not much different human nature. What is there in it for me. By using the children as the volunteers you ARE changing the future for they are willing to learn and will carry your attention into the future and future generations. I am not cinical but you teach them young and they will remember and teach their children. Keep up the good work. A touch one heart will spread like wild fire in the future.
A.H.Stever
Hi Sam,
ReplyDeleteThanks for an interesting insight into the per diem problems etc, which, as you say, we cannot really judge from our western perspective.
On a recent visit to the garden I found it being used to it's full potential by the students, who were so absorbed in their work that they didn't even notice me, another toubab visiting Kaur. So I really do think that, whatever may have been the problems in setting it up, the garden is a great success and just wanted to say well done to both of you PC volunteers who helped make it that way!!
Rob
It is always a challenge to lead people into relating to their own power within. Hand outs can definitely be debilitating. I am glad you were able to be firm while sticking with the project.
ReplyDelete